By Clive A. Gillmore, CEO and group CIO, Mondrian Investment Partners
The period since the global financial crisis is often described as a simple story: growth has won and value has been left behind. That description is directionally true at a global level, but it masks a more nuanced story beyond the US.
Growth style’s dominance has been heavily influenced by a relatively small group of US companies, more recently supported by enthusiasm surrounding AI. Across developed non-US markets, however, value has materially outperformed growth since 2022.
Reassessing growth’s global dominance
From the GFC through years of exceptionally low interest rates, long-duration growth assets benefited from falling discount rates and the emergence of a powerful group of technology winners. More recently, growth leadership has persisted, increasingly reflecting the exceptional performance of a narrow set of companies.
From 2021 to September 2026, the MSCI EAFE Value index returned 8% cumulatively relative to the MSCI World, while MSCI EAFE Growth lagged it by 33.3%; MSCI USA Growth was 14.4% ahead. The global headline therefore obscures the different experience of diversified non-US value investors.
Market leadership can persist for long periods but has changed repeatedly across regions and styles. Rather than anticipating when that leadership might reverse, the focus should remain on the prospective return available at the price paid today.
When concentration becomes concentration of risk
The exceptional performance of a relatively small number of companies has materially changed the composition of several major equity benchmarks. In September 2026, the five largest stocks represented almost 30% of MSCI USA, compared with 19% of MSCI AC World and just 8.8% of MSCI EAFE. The distinction between styles is even more striking: the five largest stocks made up 53.1% of MSCI USA Growth, compared with 24.4% of MSCI USA Value.
Concentration is not inherently problematic. Successful companies can, and should, become larger as their earnings and cashflows grow. However, a larger benchmark weight does not necessarily imply lower stock-specific risk and can increase the influence of an individual company on overall index returns and risk.
Benchmark weights tell only part of the story. Concentration becomes more consequential when the largest constituents also move increasingly in tandem. In the US, the 10 largest stocks accounted for 52.4% of estimated index risk in September 2026, compared with 16.6% in 2015. In EAFE, their risk contribution increased only modestly, from 12.5% to 14.3%.
For active managers, choosing not to own a heavily weighted constituent can itself become a significant relative-risk position, even when the portfolio remains diversified. Higher tracking error does not necessarily indicate a corresponding increase in underlying absolute risk.
Why value?
The case for value in today’s market is not predicated on the current market leaders becoming tomorrow’s losers. Successful companies can continue to grow, and structural trends such as AI can create significant economic value. The role of a value investor is not to dispute that potential, but to ask what return is available from the price investors are being asked to pay today.
A valuation-driven approach starts from a different premise: Is a security mispriced? Capital is allocated according to an independent assessment of prospective returns, based on analysis of cash flows and how they are allocated between dividends, share buybacks, reinvestment, the retirement of debt and M&A. The benchmark remains a reference for understanding portfolio exposures, not a substitute for fundamental valuation.
Value should therefore not be equated with buying low-multiple stocks or simply replicating a value index. A fundamental value investor can identify opportunities in growing technology companies where prospective cash flows justify an attractive return, just as a company trading on a low multiple can represent poor value if its fundamentals are deteriorating. A disciplined value approach identifies opportunities where current valuations do not adequately reflect long-term fundamentals, with the flexibility to seek attractive prospective real returns across a broader opportunity set.
Ultimately, the case for active value does not depend on predicting when growth leadership will reverse. It rests on the ability to identify attractive investment opportunities across a diversified universe, while maintaining the valuation discipline and flexibility to construct portfolios independently of increasingly concentrated benchmarks.














