Evident AI index: Platforms and hedge funds outpace ‘traditional’ funds

BlackRock, Vanguard, and Fidelity form top three

2–3m

Evident’s first AI index for asset managers reveals that platforms and hedge funds have achieved greater AI maturity than peers, with BlackRock, Vanguard, and Fidelity placing first, second, and third, respectively.

The report analysed data from 30 asset management firms, including traditional managers, hedge funds and scaled platforms. In total, analysts examined 320 publicly-disclosed AI use cases across four pillars: Talent, innovation, leadership and transparency.

The top nine firms account for 45% of use cases, despite comprising just 30% of the index, indicating that these companies have “pulled ahead” of the competition in AI integration. These firms have expanded their use of AI beyond “basic” productivity tools – research and summarisation – into development, distribution, and client service.

Alexandra Mousavizadeh, Evident’s co-founder and co-CEO, said: “Our first Evident AI Index for asset management shows that the leading firms are poised to accelerate away from the rest of the field, which makes benchmarking their progress more important than ever.

“For now, the evidence shows AI improving the research behind investment decisions – better models, faster analysis and richer signals – but that isn’t yet proof of alpha. Translating AI’s output to superior returns is the next frontier for the industry.”

See also: HANetf launches AI Revolution ETF with Yorkville Ives & Co

The report argues that platforms are best placed to benefit from AI deployment at a structural level. This is because standardised products and rules-based workflows are easy to automate, while millions of clients create exploitable data for scaling AI tools across the business.

By contrast, “traditional” firms have focused on enhancing their base offering: fundamental research, active portfolio management, and specialist investment expertise – fragmenting their integration and inhibiting generalised application.

Where AI is implemented, there is no single path to integration success. Vanguard tops the leadership category through deploying the most use cases; Fidelity leads talent and innovation, accounting for 34% of all AI workers, 43% of AI research output and 78% of AI patents, across the 30 firms. 

Meanwhile, hedge funds such as Bridgewater and Man Group – fourth and fifth on the index – lead on integrating AI into investment decisions. Implementation differs: Bridgewater uses machine learning to generate, test, and evaluate investment ideas, while Man Group deploys AI agents to formulate and test trading hypotheses.

However, the report also notes most companies have yet to declare quantifiable AI impact on a firm-wide level. Only three asset managers – AllianceBernstein, Carlyle Group, and Vanguard – have disclosed projected or realised returns across AI activities, with Carlyle and Vanguard disclosing realised figures of $470m and $450m.

Of all asset manager business areas, distribution offers the most reports of tangible impact from AI implementation, providing 62% of use-cases with reported outcomes. For example, Franklin Templeton reported an 11% uplift in sales and a 25% increase in client contacts in the regions its AI-powered Intelligence Hub was rolled out.

See also: Markets mount fragile recovery from AI sell-off as Nvidia CEO scandal looms

Jack McKie, Evident’s director of asset management, said: “For asset managers, value is easiest to demonstrate where the AI is furthest from the investment decision, and it’s hardest to prove where it matters most.

“As AI moves deeper into investment processes, clients, investors and regulators alike will expect transparent evidence of what it is actually being delivered.”