Mid Wynd’s Boyle: ‘The euphoric AI bubble might have burst’

Markets are finally questioning the spending of AI names

Burst your bubble thumb tack and balloon about to pop background
3–5m

Once the darling sector of global equity markets, the narrative of dominance around technology stocks seems to have been shaken this year.

In the past month alone, tech stocks were hit by multiple sharp selloffs, while Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang resigned amid scandal, and that has fed through into stock prices.

While the MSCI ACWI Information Technology and Communication Services index is still up 21.9% in sterling terms year-to-date (13 November), over the past month it is down nearly 12%, according to data from FE fundinfo.

This has generally been positive for a section of underperforming quality managers, including Nick Train, with Finsbury Growth & Income Trust experiencing one of its best months on record during October.

Another quality manager that benefitted from this tech underperformance is Alistair Boyle, director of the Mid Wynd International Investment Trust, who argued more cracks could appear in the AI story if these sell-offs continue.

“I think, whatever happens from today, whether the market starts or stops buying AI stocks, the euphoric bubble around it has burst,” Boyle told Portfolio Adviser. “I’m not sure you can put that genie back in the bottle.”

See also: Fairview’s Yearsley: Tech shares finally dip as Lindsell Train delivers ‘surprise’

As an example, he pointed to the Nasdaq Philadelphia Stock Exchange Semiconductor index (or SOX), a popular measure of the performance of the largest US semiconductor stocks. Over the past six months, it’s down 8% according to data from FE fundinfo, but at its worst it was down by as much as 22%.

That said, year-to-date, the index has still delivered handsomely for investors, rising more than 50% according to FE fundinfo data.

So, what exactly convinced Boyle that this six-month underperformance from AI stocks is the start of a genuine change, instead of a minor spike in volatility?

“It’s absolutely right to question if this can continue, because what markets always tend to do is extrapolate on the way up and down,” he said. “But I think when you’ve been around for as long as I have, you know that whenever there’s a euphoric piece of tech it’s very difficult to bet against until it gets a sense check.”

To that end, he stressed that it’s not the case that AI as an investment theme is dying, just that the euphoria associated with it is finally heading for a “sense check” moment, akin to 1999/2000 or last year for precious metals.

Investors are questioning what return there will be on the amount of capex being poured into artificial intelligence, both by private companies such as fast-approaching Anthropic IPO or by more public companies, he argued.

“The market is finally asking what sort of returns you’re going to get on this compute investment,” Boyle said.

Additionally, with more of this money being raised through debt, AI hyperscalers are now competing with governments, which are also trying to issue a huge amount of debt for their own fiscal policies, he explained.

See also: Saranac’s Urwin: AI has come for the bond market, but not how you think 

“I think that’s created a situation where the euphoria we saw in the second quarter has unwound, and that’s started to accelerate in recent months.”

It’s not just tech-specific indices being impacted, he noted, with the Kospi retail index also hit hard by this reassessment of AI spending.

“The idea of a sense check that these great valuations from AI stocks will not go on forever is now a possibility; it’s now in the shop window.”

As a quality investor, this is throwing up some exciting opportunities at compelling valuations that could be poised for a comeback if this underperformance from AI stocks continues into a third or even fourth quarter, he said.

“The market has become almost like a meme stock in terms of how short-term it is,” he said. “The market is just much quicker than us; if it has a sniff of an idea, it doesn’t just de-rate something by 5% or 10% anymore.”

This has left many quality businesses with extremely low expectations baked into their share price, a common argument made by quality investors, but one that Boyle believed was increasingly supported by earnings.

“When you look at the Q3 reported earnings of most of the companies they own, we saw something like Accenture up 25% on its numbers, albeit on very low expectations.”

It’s since risen further, up by 57% as of 13 November, according to Google Finance. This has allowed it to claw back most of the losses from the SaaSpocalypse earlier this year, which hit companies like Accenture hard.

“I think we’re going to go back to asking what a good business is, what its competitive returns look like, and so on,” Boyle concluded. In that case, he argued there may be room for a genuine comeback in quality investing, and investors may start to appreciate good businesses with solid economic moats again.

See also: Markets on edge as Nvidia scandal takes another twist