At Dart, Butcher will be responsible for investment research, portfolio management, and building relationships with intermediaries.
Butcher left Brewin late last year after a nine-year spell to take a short break from the industry.
Privately owned and managed by its two majority shareholders, chief executive Richard Whitehead and director Matthew Wille, London-based Dart Capital manages portfolios ranging from £200,000 to £20m.
"We are delighted to welcome Matthew to the firm," Whitehead said. "He brings with him huge experience in wealth management and we look forward to using his input to help build on our successful private client business and intermediary services," he added.
"I am very pleased to be joining Dart Capital at this exciting phase in their development," Butcher said. "Our industry faces both challenge and opportunity and I believe that the firm is well placed to benefit from the growth in our sector through a genuinely client-focussed service," he added.